
(Or: Why I Love Christmas, Trains and my Big Brother.)
Books are, obviously, a fairly huge part of my life. I have six overflowing bookcases in my bedroom, one of which I may be trading in for a larger case in the near future because this Christmas I hit the book lover jackpot: about 85% of what I received (and what I gave others, come to think of it) was books. Most notably: my sister got me "Girl Sleuth" (a book on Nancy Drew and her creators), my mother gave me two large shopping bags full of antiquarian childrens books and my older brother, who usually does not get me anything, got me two amazing books- Oscar Wilde's Fairy Tales (Signet Classics, so it features a neat "about the author in relation to this book" sort of introduction) and "The Man Who Loved Books Too Much", a book that my bookstore cannot seem to keep stocked for more than a few hours after the latest order comes in.
I am always a little wary of really popular books- I started working at Boswell's Books during the rise of the Twilight Saga- but also terribly interested in what the fuss is about. Not interested enough to really follow through with buying and reading the book for the most part, but intrigued enough that should, say, my brother give me a copy... I would not mind cracking it open.
Guess what? I can see what the fuss is about in this one. That said, I was half convinced that this book was going to make me physically sick. Not sure if it was the subject matter or the fact that I read most of this book on trains to and from New York. (Does anyone else find the smell of the dining car completely unbearable?) This is a book about a rare book thief (not about my ideal boyfriend, as the title might otherwise imply) and the "detective" bookseller who tracked him down. It is also about the world of book collecting, selling and stealing, with enough random book related data to make any bookworm smile. This book did make me smile, but, as I said, it also made me uncomfortable.
Books are not dollar store candy, stealing them (to me) is not something that ought to be seen as a game. Stealing a book is like stealing a painting- it is not just stealing from the owner/seller, it is stealing from the world. I work in a bookstore which sort of adds to the ill I feel toward the theif in the book... but most of it is that Gilkey, the theif in the book, could not display his "library" to anyone. Stolen rare books, again like paintings, have a way of disappearing after being stolen.
Another queasy point was the motive. Books, owning books, as a sign of wealth. I know my personal library is impressive, but that is not the point of having books for me. For me... books are for reference- be it something actually in their pages or just summoned by the nostalgia of looking at them. They are also for lending so I can share a conversation or two with friends about their contents. Gilkey... the books were to impress others and show them an identity- that of a cultured gentleman- except that he *cannot* show these books off. They are stolen, no matter how impressive they are, so they are hidden away. That... does not sound like "loving" books to me, it just sounds spiteful. What good is a book if it cannot be read and shared?
Enough spoliers now, this is meant to be a review. Here is my conclusions on the book: inspite of any unease this book may have caused me, and perhaps because of said unease, this book is damn good. It even feels like a good book. The pages are cut in a sort of "frayed" manner (this is at least true of the hardcover) which gives an interesting texture. I am postive this is intentional- that this is for making the book feel like the rare books it talks about. (Personally, I think that is awesome. Anything that adds to the importance of "bookness" is something I treasure- as far as I can tell ebooks do not have frayed, bendable pages.) The story (which is true, did I mention that?) is well paced and easy to follow- while still surprising the reader once in awhile. A fine piece of journalism turned personal narrative and one I reccomend to booklovers everywhere. Borrow it from a library or buy it from an independent bookseller- I promise you, this one is worth the fuss.